Devil’s advocate

A Devil's Advocate is someone who will bring up a contrarian or opposing view, to challenge the ideas or plans of the group. Often, the Devil's Advocate doesn't actually support this contrarian view, but they bring it up to force the team to defend the plan.

The Devil's Advocate can ask questions like "can you defend that choice?", or "what happens if we're wrong about our estimated pace?" or "what if we're wrong and that slope slides...then what?"

It can be socially taxing to take on this role, so we recommend assigning someone to play the role, and to change who will play the role throughout a day. It's much easier to maintain friendships when you can attribute your contrarian idea to the role assigned to you. It can also be challenging to listen to someone who is constantly presenting contrarian opinions, so everyone needs to be open to the idea.

By giving this a try in the field you'll developing your own abilities while improving this resource for everyone.

I'll try thisI have tried this

Devil’s advocate

How to do it

A Devil's Advocate is someone who will bring up a contrarian or opposing view, to challenge the ideas or plans of the group. Often, the Devil's Advocate doesn't actually support this contrarian view, but they bring it up to force the team to defend the plan.

The Devil's Advocate can ask questions like "can you defend that choice?", or "what happens if we're wrong about our estimated pace?" or "what if we're wrong and that slope slides...then what?"

It can be socially taxing to take on this role, so we recommend assigning someone to play the role, and to change who will play the role throughout a day. It's much easier to maintain friendships when you can attribute your contrarian idea to the role assigned to you. It can also be challenging to listen to someone who is constantly presenting contrarian opinions, so everyone needs to be open to the idea.

The why behind it

Having a Devil's Advocate forces you to defend your plans and decisions. it will help you avoid problems of groupthink, and you'll be more likely to consider new options. If you can't defend your plans when they're challenged, maybe you should come up with a new plan.

Put it in your own words

hey i have an idea…

Who wants to play the Devil's Advocate role today?
Let's split up the day and have each person play the Devil's Advocate role for part of the day
Previous
No previous card
Next
No next card
Great Choice
Investigate your intuition and and it's longer
Next, try it and tell us how it goes
Give it a go on your next tour or ride. Even if you don't use it or like it please come back and share that feedback. It improves the toolkit for everyone.
We can send you an email reminder
It really helps us count which practices for our research.
Your submission has been received!
We hope you have a great tour or ride.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.